2001- John & Ann Louise Urzendowski Micek, SM ’49 Msgr. Paul F. Peter, posthumous
2002 - Michael T. DeFreece
2003 - Gene & Marilyn Spence
2004 - Maurice E. Cox, Jr.
2005 - Gloria Jezewski Flynn, SJ ’50+
2006 - Robert H. Matt+
2007 - Dick & Mary Pat Smola McCormick ’58
2008 - The Sisters of Mercy
2009 - Kevin McCoy
2010 - Larry B. Good
2011 - Edward T. Regan
2012 - Wayne+ & Eileen+ Krebs Ryan, SM ’45
2013 - Carolyn Jaworski ’64
2014 - Louise Battaglia Franco, SM ’50
2015 - The Sisters of Mercy
2016 - Mercy High School 60th Anniversary
2017 - Ingrid Kalinowski Borghoff ’65
2019 - John & Nicole Hahn Jesse ’80
2020 - Sr. Johanna Burnell, RSM
2021 - Sr. Corrine Connelly, RSM '58
2022 - David & Mary Franco Levy '70
2023 - Holly McCoy 2024 - Sr. Jeanne O'Rourke, RSM
+ Deceased